Ocean Jigsaw Puzzle Piece Series - Music and Maritime History
[2021年03月17日(Wed)]
Recently I was looking over some CD compilations made by Nakamura Toyo back in the 80s and 90s and started to think about the connections between music and history. Nakamura founded Music Magazine, a Japanese magazine that was a pioneer in introducing readers to a wide variety of non-mainstream popular music genres along with refreshingly opinionated commentary. After getting to know Nakamura and translating many of his works, I tried applying his view of music as a series of intangible artefacts: forms coming into being, flourishing, and while sometimes ceasing to grow, never entirely disappearing, but affecting history. For example, one of his themes that made a big impression on me was the origin and role of “call-and-response” in the development of popular music.
He often cited the American musicologist Alan Lomax, who recorded many examples of work songs by those actually laboring in fields, forests, or on railroads in the 1930s. Growing up in the American south, the connection between blues music and work on the farm seemed an obvious one to me. It was only when I understood the use of “call-and-response” in synchronizing activity among groups, and that the form had long existed in West Africa and was brought over by slaves, that I realized the importance of intangible artefacts and how tracing them could illuminate connections in history. Those sung in the southern part of the U.S. were the roots out of which gospel, blues, and rock and roll eventually grew. Up until my parents’ generation, before the invention of sophisticated farming machinery, people still picked cotton under the hot Tennessee sun to songs like “Pick a Bale of Cotton” that Lomax had recorded. Unfortunately, many examples of these intangible cultural artefacts, passed on and refined generation after generation, have now disappeared forever.
If people naturally seek to lighten the burden of simple repetitive labor or to synchronize their exertions for maximum effect through the chanting of songs in unison or in a call-and-response format, we can easily imagine them taking place as the pyramids or the Great Wall of China were being built. A similar situation pertains to work at sea. Our certain knowledge only goes back a few centuries
but references in extant written sources and pottery provide some hints into the relation between music and onboard work. For example, The Olympias, a trireme reconstructed in the 1980s, based on ancient Greek sources, employs 170 rowers on three levels. Old movies used to show ancient coxswains coordinating their rowers at sea with loud, rhythmical drumbeats, but trials on The Olympias showed that melodies played on “auletes” (double pipes with reeds and a bagpipe-like sound) were more effective in keeping the long overlapping oars from getting entangled. We know from documents
that aulete players were part of ancient crews, but still lack evidence for any songs that might have been sung.

Image of Trireme
(Source: 1.bp.blogspot.com)
but references in extant written sources and pottery provide some hints into the relation between music and onboard work. For example, The Olympias, a trireme reconstructed in the 1980s, based on ancient Greek sources, employs 170 rowers on three levels. Old movies used to show ancient coxswains coordinating their rowers at sea with loud, rhythmical drumbeats, but trials on The Olympias showed that melodies played on “auletes” (double pipes with reeds and a bagpipe-like sound) were more effective in keeping the long overlapping oars from getting entangled. We know from documents
that aulete players were part of ancient crews, but still lack evidence for any songs that might have been sung.
Image of Trireme
(Source: 1.bp.blogspot.com)
The need for synchronization of effort also applied to
sailing ships. As riggings became more extensive, moving to three and even four masts from the 15th century onwards, hoisting and lowering of the greater number of sails required a higher level of coordination by crews. On whaling ships in the 19th century the work was compounded by the hunt. What emerged out of this demand for synchronization and endurance, in different languages and eras, was called in English the sea shanty.
sailing ships. As riggings became more extensive, moving to three and even four masts from the 15th century onwards, hoisting and lowering of the greater number of sails required a higher level of coordination by crews. On whaling ships in the 19th century the work was compounded by the hunt. What emerged out of this demand for synchronization and endurance, in different languages and eras, was called in English the sea shanty.
I had long been aware of the term and knew, probably from old movies, that singing often accompanied work on board ships, but the last few years has seen an explosion of interest in the sea shanty. People around the world are now enjoying as a musical form on the stage, YouTube, but especially TikTok, what grew spontaneously out of harsh and dangerous conditions, the result of trial
and error by sailors, not musicians, over hundreds of years. The 1956 movie version of Moby Dick included several renditions of shanties and ballads; there were also many in the 2019 musical. In 2018, the English sea shanty group The Longest Johns included the song “Soon May the Wellerman Come” on their popular album Between Wind and Water.
However, what is now considered the worldwide sea shanty movement began when a young Scottish postman named Nathan Evans posted his version of the same song on TikTok in January of this year. By February it was the number one song on the UK, German, Dutch, and Swiss music charts and is now being constantly remixed on TikTok. It’s a whaling song that can be traced back to New Zealand in the mid-nineteenth century, and is sung from the perspective of the crew on board a whaling ship who are desperately waiting for supplies from the Weller Brothers whaling station in Otago.

Image of sea shanty No.1
(Source: Publicdomainreview.org)
and error by sailors, not musicians, over hundreds of years. The 1956 movie version of Moby Dick included several renditions of shanties and ballads; there were also many in the 2019 musical. In 2018, the English sea shanty group The Longest Johns included the song “Soon May the Wellerman Come” on their popular album Between Wind and Water.
However, what is now considered the worldwide sea shanty movement began when a young Scottish postman named Nathan Evans posted his version of the same song on TikTok in January of this year. By February it was the number one song on the UK, German, Dutch, and Swiss music charts and is now being constantly remixed on TikTok. It’s a whaling song that can be traced back to New Zealand in the mid-nineteenth century, and is sung from the perspective of the crew on board a whaling ship who are desperately waiting for supplies from the Weller Brothers whaling station in Otago.
Image of sea shanty No.1
(Source: Publicdomainreview.org)
Perhaps the new-found popularity of the genre is related to the pandemic: people are attracted to the shanties because they are simple, upbeat, and were meant to be sung in groups, so are ideal for mashups, which, though online, gives the sense of collaboration and so can reduce the stress of quarantines. However, even before the pandemic and latest boom, sea shanties were being kept alive by enthusiasts in fishermen’s associations around the U.K. and by the Wellington Sea Shanty Society in New Zealand. It is also taught in the cultural component of the SEA Semester run out of Woods Hole, MA. in the U.S., where students also spend time on research voyages. Even in Japan, the Sailingship Nippon-maru Fan Male Choir has performed sea shanties at their concerts for the past twenty-five years. In England, the Falmouth International Sea Shanty Festival draws crowds of 60,000, but will unfortunately have to be held virtually this year.

Image of sea shanty No.2
(Source: americanheritagemusic.com)
Image of sea shanty No.2
(Source: americanheritagemusic.com)
The shanty boom was foreshadowed by the 2010 BBC documentary Shanties and Sea Songs with Gareth Malone, which gives a good picture of the historical background of the shanty around the U.K. and shows how the singing tradition has been carried on by choral groups in different ports and fishing villages and is still part of the work of active fishermen in Cornwall.
However, just as the work songs of field and forest
died out with the coming of agricultural machinery, when ships turned to steam in the nineteenth century the work routines on board changed and the sea shanty lost its role. Luckily, in the 1920s, the American scholar James Madison Carpenter toured the U.K. to record the last of those who had actively sung shanties on ship in their youth, providing authentication for how they are sung today.
died out with the coming of agricultural machinery, when ships turned to steam in the nineteenth century the work routines on board changed and the sea shanty lost its role. Luckily, in the 1920s, the American scholar James Madison Carpenter toured the U.K. to record the last of those who had actively sung shanties on ship in their youth, providing authentication for how they are sung today.
Thanks to the emerging technology of a hundred years ago, combined with TikTok and YouTube, marine artefacts from centuries past have been revived and are again part of our cultural vocabulary. This bodes well for teaching aspects of maritime history that are often overlooked, but more importantly, it’s fun!
John A. Dolan
Research Fellow
The Ocean Policy Research Institute
John A. Dolan
Research Fellow
The Ocean Policy Research Institute


